Hermès Exotic Finishes: Matte vs. Shiny
How each finish is made, which construction it belongs on, the matte price reversal, and the new Boreal Satin
Similar to how many Hermès collectors have a preference for either Gold or Palladium hardware, many also develop a strong preference for a particular exotic finish. For crocodile and alligator, Hermès produces both Matte and Shiny — also referred to as Lisse — finishes. Understanding how each is made explains why they behave so differently in use, and why their secondary market values have moved in opposite directions over the past five years.
How the finishes are made
Shiny / Lisse
The glossy effect of Shiny crocodile or alligator is not produced by an applied glaze or coating. It is achieved through repeated buffing of the scales with a smooth agate stone until they approach mirror reflectivity. The process compresses and polishes the scale surface itself. The result is rigid — Shiny crocodile bags are significantly stiffer than Matte examples, and the scale surface can develop permanent matte spots wherever even a single drop of water makes contact. With heavy use, wrinkles can develop on the scales, particularly at the flap.
Matte
The Matte finish is achieved through the use of wool felt rubbed against the skin into a smooth, soft texture. Rather than compressing the scale surface, the process creates a velvety, pliable result — Matte bags are noticeably softer and more flexible than Shiny examples. Matte exotics are not prone to water spotting or use-wrinkles. In lighter colors, Matte alligator can absorb darkening from skin contact through oil or moisturizer transfer, but dark Matte bags are largely spared any such concerns.
Finish conventions by construction
The general convention at Hermès is that Sellier Kellys are made with Shiny crocodile or alligator, while Retourne Kellys are done in Matte. This rule is not rigidly held to, however:
Sellier Mini Kelly II (20cm) examples are found in Matte alligator. Hermès has recently produced limited edition Sellier Kelly 28s in Matte Alligator — including the Vanille Alligator Touch Kelly with a Butler leather handle, and bi-finish examples featuring Shiny Alligator bodies with Matte gussets and sangles. Full Matte Sellier Kellys do exist on the secondary market, primarily at 32cm and documented in Matte Blue Brighton, Ébène, and Poudre — but examples are few and far between. Shiny Alligator Retourne Kellys were produced in the 1990s in both 32cm and 35cm, primarily in Miel with Gold hardware, though other colors were also produced.
For Birkins, all sizes are found in both Matte and Shiny crocodile or alligator. The recently introduced Sellier Birkins have also been spotted in both finishes.
Secondary market data — the matte reversal
Note: auction data below reflects results through mid-2022. The directional trends described remain accurate as market intelligence; specific price levels have continued to evolve.
Approximately 60% of crocodile and alligator Birkins and Kellys sold at auction carry a Shiny finish — reflecting historical production proportions. But the secondary market has been repricing Matte's relative rarity with increasing conviction over the past five years, and the shift is now substantial.
| Year | Matte vs. Shiny average price differential | Direction |
|---|---|---|
| 2017 | Matte averaged ~$13,000 less than Shiny | Shiny premium |
| 2021 | Matte averaged ~$5,000 more than Shiny | Matte premium emerging |
| 2022 (to mid-year) | Matte averaged ~$10,000 more than Shiny | Matte premium established |
The size-by-size breakdown is more specific. The largest differential is at 28cm Kelly — Matte versions averaged approximately $30,000 more than Shiny over 2021–2022. Matte 25cm Birkins and Kellys have consistently averaged more than Shiny versions, with a ~$6,500 premium sustained over the previous five years. Shiny crocodile and alligator Birkin 35s still averaged slightly more than Matte at the larger scale as of 2022, with a ~6% Shiny premium — though the expectation is that large Matte Birkins will follow the same trajectory as smaller sizes as large-bag demand returns and the rarity of quality Matte examples becomes more broadly understood.
A new finish: Boreal Satin
A new finish termed Boreal Satin has begun emerging from Hermès' workshops. First seen primarily in bracelets, Boreal Satin alligator Constance bags have begun appearing on the secondary market. The finish sits perceptually between Matte and Shiny — a satin quality rather than a flat or mirror surface. Documented colorways include Nata, Blue Brume, Jaune Citron, and Rose Bubblegum — with Blue Brume, Jaune Citron, and Rose Bubblegum representing new colors in Hermès' exotic palette that have not appeared in standard Matte or Shiny production.
Sellier Birkins and Sellier Kellys in Boreal Satin alligator are anticipated as the format extends beyond bracelets and Constances into the primary bag formats.
The practical case for Matte: The secondary market's repricing of Matte reflects what experienced collectors have always known: Matte exotics are more wearable, more forgiving in use, and more resistant to the specific vulnerabilities (water spotting, use-wrinkles, permanent scale compression) that make Shiny bags demanding to carry. The 60/40 Shiny/Matte production split means Matte supply is structurally constrained. The combination of lower supply, genuine wearability advantages, and rising collector recognition of those advantages explains the sustained price reversal — and suggests it is likely to continue.
Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.